Posts Tagged Anti Social Marketing

Trust Me!

4
Digg me

Back around 2005 I had an office that when you walked through the main door you were in our production pit. It was usually fine because we were a production company and we didn’t get any walk in business.

One day though, a guy walks into our office and says loudly “Hey there! How ya doing?” We all get up and someone responds, “Hey! Good. You?”

We all look slightly confused as not one of us recognizes the person right off the bat.

He goes on “What are ya doing today? You busy?”

Me, “Fairly. A few things on the go…how about you?”  I’m being extremely friendly, wracking my brain as to who this person is. I’m starting to panic as he knows us and by the look on everyone’s faces we don’t know him! Is he a client?! Is he crew?!

Him-“I’m great! I was thinking about you folks the other day so I thought I would drop by.”

I’m fucked.  I really don’t remember this guy…not uncommon as our client/supplier list is well over 400 people but normally with everyone around we should have someone able to place him…I get the courage.  “I’m so sorry.  I can’t remember your name…”

Him- “No problem it’s Bob! So, the office looks great!”

Me- “Bob, sorry, but how do I know you?” I say smiling.

Bob- “Well, I don’t know if you do, but I have a great selection of books that I’m offering to select company…” I interrupt.  “Wait…You don’t know us?”

I’m not going to say what happened next…it just got stupid..

Funny story and it’s true.  But what’s my point?  There is a line that can’t be crossed during any point in the sales cycle but especially at the very beginning.  Don’t pretend that you know me.  Be friendly and welcoming but don’t fake a relationship!  For me, the second I loose trust within the cycle, I’m out of it and usually very peeved for someone wasting my time.

Now you’re thinking “Bob” is a pretty rare occurrence, but he isn’t.  We just need to see all the “Bob’s” out there for who and what they are.

A few days ago I got an email telling me about a local service.  The way the email was formatted it looked like I would know the person or the company.   I had to wrack my brain the same way as with Bob, only to discover, I didn’t know them! It was a bloody waste of time trying to figure out a connection because there wasn’t any.  It was Spam.  Spam, Spam, Spam!

One of the main rules in sales is you need to gain the targets trust. These people didn’t, in fact just the opposite.  They had no clue about it and it seems to be happening time and again with many other companies and their email marketing.  You get added to an email list, ad hock and without your knowing.

There are multiple reasons for having a person’s permission before adding them to an email list.  The most serious is, without permission, your email is Spam and believe it or not, most hosting companies have rules against sending Spam! I have actually seen hosting companies have their entire list of clients banned from sending emails to other hosting companies.  As such most hosting companies take Spam very seriously now.  Less serous legally, but more important for your sales, you loose your chance to have a conversation with your prospect if you are in the junk mail folder or worse, pissed them off!

Being friendly I sent the Spammer an email a day later explaining a little about email marketing and a couple of pointers as to how she might have been a little more successful in contacting me…….I don’t think she gave a rat’s ass… I believe she thinks, as most people who make the same mistake do, Email Marketing is suppose to be easy and people being pissed off about Spam is just part of the course.  It’s not!  Email Marketing can be a rewarding relationship, if you offer something of value.  If you do, chances are the recipient will let you keep emailing them giving you multiple chances at a sale.  If you offer no value and have not taken the time to make it of value then why would we keep letting you fill our in box and wasting our time?

On the surface Email Marketing  just looks like it would be getting and managing a mailing list.  It’s not. If your are going to put people on an email list, at least take the 20 seconds (if that) to send a personal email to them asking to do so…  Gain a little bit of trust first and then build on it!  It also allows them to say no and them saying no is not all bad.  It gives you information on the prospect (email is legit, signature bar, etc), starts a conversation and allows you to tailor the message better to that prospect and to others (they might have unique needs that you didn’t know about and didn’t tailor your introduction message to).

Let me help you just in case you are still not going to make the effort….

 

Dear (insert company here),

I have come across your company while researching possible clients for our services.  Every now and then we send out information that you might be interested in about (what you do/sell).  We promise that you will find it of use and interesting.  If you don’t want to be included on the mailing list, please let us know and you will not receive anymore emails from us.  Further after receiving any future emails, you can still decide at that time, not to receive anymore.

Thank you for your time and hope we can be of service to you in the future,

 

(your name here..YOUR REAL NAME!)

 

Please feel free to cut and paste, but remember to replace (insert company here) and (your name here) with the appropriate information….nothing says stupid like getting emails with it still there…and I do get them!

 

Anyone remember the old days of Fax spam? …….. Ok, there used to a machine that, when connected up to a regular wired phone line, would transmit black and white images to another Fax somewhere else. Some companies would hire a “Fax marketing company” to send out Spam Ads to any and every fax number in a select area.  It was all about “the list”.  Cheep flights, cheap cruises, cleaning, Fax and copy repair, you name it, it would just appear on your fax machine eating up your toner, paper and God forbid…your thermal paper roll!

Well one day some bright fellow thought of a way to get even.  They would find out the advertisers business Fax number and send them a looped black page, called a “black fax”…ok…A what? A black fax was exactly what it sounds like.  You would tape four pieces of black paper together with a strip of exposed tape at the top so you could join the bottom piece into a roll.  You would dial the offending number, hit send on the fax and as the paper starts feeding through you would take the leading edge of the paper that just went through the Fax scanner and attach it to the last edge so you have an endless loop of black. Unless the person on the other end is paying attention to their Fax, they would end up with no toner or paper or worse….AN EMPTY THERMAL PAPER ROLL!

To the Fax marketing company and their clients, the “list” was everything, until they got feed back (pay back?) from the folks who they pissed off.  Don’t let your email marketing be like Fax Spam! You have to see your prospects as more than a list.  You have to earn trust and the first step in email marketing is to do that!

If anyone discovers a “black fax” trick for spam email, please let me know.  Also, I always wondered whether “Bob’s” tactic worked well in large offices where there was a certain amount of anonymity….I wonder what he is doing now?

 

Scott Westerlaken

With over 25 years of award winning experience in marketing, television commercials, film, video, communications, web, radio, print, and events, Scott has the ability to maintain focus on the big picture and offer a wide range of solutions appropriate to the clients message and budget. He has been recognized with dozens of awards in business, communications, and filmmaking from around the world. For the client, this means a truly unique balance of hands on technical knowledge and high level strategic experience that always leads to unique and creative solutions.

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

Just because you own a car doesn’t mean you’re qualified to drive an F1 car!

6
Digg me

It started about five years ago when semi pro equipment started to become more financially within reach. Although my friend Al Graham says it all started in 1984 when the first Mac hit the market. Everyone with a camera and a Mac can now thinks they are qualified to do your company’s communication.

But I beg to differ… there is a lot more to telling your company’s story than just the accessible equipment, images and music! To craft an effective message your communications company must know more than the latest technology, they need to understand marketing and effective messaging to create a story that enhances your brand and objectives!

Hell, they might even have some insights into you potential target audience. It’s important that your communications team looks at what your target is looking for and not just what “you” want to say. The two are different and some folks can’t get over the “what I want to say is…”

The way I like to look at effective communications is by putting myself into the target’s shoes. What is going to motivate me to take the desired action and the opposite, what will I find un-motivating, boring, and or not important in the proposed messaging.

Your communications company also needs to have the experience, training and balls to tell you what you don’t need to say or show when you ask for something irrelevant to the messaging. Don’t you love seeing the TV ads where the entire family of the business owner is used in the commercial?! That really enhances the messaging!

We did some great videos for Inland Technologies this past fall that we have been using as great examples of getting specific points across to the target, and also avoiding technical points that, although vital to the making the services work, are not really vital to the viewer making the initial decision to initiate the sales cycle. Their President really summed it up well, “the services we provide are to make the clients problems disappear”.  Funny, but I think that a lot business’ forget that is really what they do! Would love to get your thoughts.

Scott Westerlaken

Scott Westerlaken

With over 25 years of award winning experience in marketing, television commercials, film, video, communications, web, radio, print, and events, Scott has the ability to maintain focus on the big picture and offer a wide range of solutions appropriate to the clients message and budget. He has been recognized with dozens of awards in business, communications, and filmmaking from around the world. For the client, this means a truly unique balance of hands on technical knowledge and high level strategic experience that always leads to unique and creative solutions.

Tags: , , , , , ,

I-Spy

4
Digg me
Scott Westerlaken

Scott Westerlaken

I spy on my competition.  I’m very open about it.  I do it ethically by monitoring their activity on the web (as I have written about before, http://www.phigroup.ca/blog/2010/01/narcissism-or-market-research/).  It’s all above board and such.  I consider my competition’s internet conversations to be the same as them having a conversation in a public place…they should expect to be over heard.
Recently I was sent an unsolicited email from someone who was using an automated email marketing “solution” and a whole bunch of issues on privacy and expectations came flooding back to me.  The email marketing “solution” in question was one I had used years earlier and truthfully kind of bothered me with all the info they collected from the recipient who opens the email. At the time I decided that it was not for “me” as I felt my clients would be upset if they ever found out.

This leads me to my biggest email pet peeves. If I don’t know you, don’t send me a blanket email asking for money for your son or daughter’s band trip to Europe.  Don’t put my email on a mailing list just because we connected on LinkedIn, Facebook, or Twitter!  Finally, my BIGGEST….DON’T monitor what emails I did read, forward and/or the time I spent on something you sent me that I might have found interesting enough to read.  It’s MY email once I get it and if you want to know what I do with it, ask me.  With a lot of the email marketing programs this is exactly what they do, but they don’t ask!  They report back a bunch of stat’s (they vary from program to program) about who opened, blocked, forwarded (and to whom, where it starts again), how long they spent with the email open, how many times they opened it, the operating system, email program, and more.  ALL without the reader’s acceptance to share that info.  Further, they don’t even knowing that it’s happening.

I was having one of “those” days I and so opted out and finally put the keyword block on for the offending “solution”.  I tweeted this and the reaction (or lack there of) was kind of surprising.  Folks liked the offender and marketing solution they offered!  They liked being able to add people without an “opt in”!  They didn’t really care about all the data that was sent without the reader knowing or allowing.  I was blown away!  Aren’t we the same folks that get’s peeved when Facebook uses our data and info without our knowledge?!

blocked emailA friend emailed about why I took the actions I did as they were about to recommend the same “solution” to their client.   I explained my feelings on “opt in” and having people know exactly what info they are giving to someone else, rather than not telling or hiding it.  They are reconsidering now…I felt a little better about her “reconsideration” though I know it’s probably too tempting for the client…and if they don’t do it their competition will.

So, here I am.  Feeling like a lone crusader once again… Feeling that if we knew “all” the info that was being collected with those fancy HTML emails (and I know I don’t know what the “all” is) we would be darn upset!  Maybe not…. I know my solution for now is to block certain company keywords…maybe next it will be HTML…

SW

With over 25 years of award winning experience in marketing, television commercials, film, video, communications, web, radio, print, and events, Scott has the ability to maintain focus on the big picture and offer a wide range of solutions appropriate to the clients message and budget. He has been recognized with dozens of awards in business, communications, and filmmaking from around the world. For the client, this means a truly unique balance of hands on technical knowledge and high level strategic experience that always leads to unique and creative solutions.

Tags: , , , ,

Lazy Boy and Lazy Creative

1
Digg me

Talking Recliners and Sub Ovens that have Children.

Do you find watching TV a little depressing lately? Well I do.

One evening of viewing and one can’t help but wonder what happened to the creative advertising industry.

Take for example the series of spots that recently aired for Lazy Boy. In each spot we are asked to believe that recliners can talk. Wow what a premise!  Can you imagine the creative brief for this one? If that unbelievable premise ain’t bad enough how about a sub oven that, under physcotherapy, confesses to being a guys parent.

Neither of these spots is funny. Some lazy bastard, or worse a group of them, foisted these pieces of excrement on the client and beat their asses home – where being creatively responsible is not a prerequisite.

Al Graham

From People or Planes 1974 Gordon Willson

From People or Planes 1974 Gordon Willson

Al Graham is a veteran of the advertising wars who once smoked like Mad Men’s Don Draper. He is also a veteran of many social conflict wars and has been actively involved in protesting dumps, airports, expressways and urban sprawl.

Tags: , , , , , ,

How Was Your Meal Tonight?

2
Digg me

As you finish your meal at most restaurants the staff will ask you how your meal was. Standard operating procedure for them and it makes absolute sense…  Get feed back in case something went wrong so maybe they might be able to fix it before you leave and spread the negative reviews.  Additionally, not asking would be implying they didn’t care about the customer’s experience.  Seems smart doesn’t it?  Yet most business other than the hospitality industry forget to ask (or worse listen)  “how they did”. By setting up a twitter search filter within their Twitter program and using Google Alerts Blog narcissism or market research a business can take care of such issues .  Not only does it give you a heads up as to what your customers really think but it shows your company cares when you publicly and proactively take care of complaints.

Recently I rented a vehicle with Hertz for a shoot.  When we picked up the vehicle they asked our plans and they upgraded the rental (at  no additional charge) to a model that would better suit our needs.  During the last part of the rental, however, the rear hatch failed and we had to do our loading and unloading through the passenger doors for a day, not a huge deal.  Upon returning the vehicle they asked how everything went and I explained it was great except for the hatch.  They promptly gave us a day off our rental contract for the minor inconvenience.  Fantastic!  That afternoon I tweeted the experience and thanked Hertz.  Within five minutes I had a direct tweet back from Hertz with a thank you.  Shocking!  I decided to do some research and discovered Hertz were following their name in Twitter and actively responding to comments and complaint issues (and in the open!).  SMART!

A few days latter I received a call from Dell Customer Support.  Having dealt with Dell support before I was mildly curious as to why they were calling.  The conversation started by the rep asking me if I was happy with my Dell and if I had experienced any problems during the past year. Ah!  Finally Dell is showing they care (if you have experienced Dell Customers Support in the past you will know what I am referring to)!  I went overdell the small issues I’ve had and the work arounds (using posts from other Dell users and not from Dell’s site) and expected to hear how they have some solution for me…To my dismay, the call quickly moved to a sales pitch for the extended warranty!   I emphatically told them I was not interested.  We went back and forth and I explained how I didn’t need the $400 extended warranty at which point she went into full script mode for 3 minutes without letting me get a word in.  I put the phone on hands free and went back to what I was doing before she called.  Eventually she hung up.  I twitted the experience expecting to get a response like I did from Hertz.  Hertz is a car rental company, Dell is a technology company….surely Dell would be as or more advanced than Hertz!  Nope. Nothing.  Now what was suppose to increase Dells revenue has only succeeded in further frustrating a customer.  FYI, a few days ago they called again…I explained they had already called me and I wasn’t interested….they hung up. Wow, not smart, but it appears that’s The Dell “standard operating procedure”!

Coincidently in the same week I sat down with my new friend Ross Simmonds (Twitter-TheCoolestCool)  rossfor a beer.  We started talking about my recent experiences with companies using twitter as a customer support tool and he told me one of his experiences with Aliant Mobility.  He twitted about being dissatisfied with a support call on his account….and know who contacted him back via Twitter?  Rogers Mobility!  Yes, Rogers.  Now that’s taking it to the next level.

It takes all of a few seconds to do a Twitter search and just a little longer to set up a Google Alert.  Not following your brand and company on Twitter and via Google Alerts is the same as saying I don’t care about what my customers experience with my company.  Why?  You’re not listening to what they have to say about the experience!  It would be the same as the waiter not asking how your meal was.  So, on that note, how did you enjoy this blog today? Can I get you anything else? :)

SW

Scott Westerlaken

Scott Westerlaken

With over 25 years of award winning experience in television, film, video, marketing, communications, web, radio, print, and events, Scott Westerlaken has the ability to maintain focus on the big picture and offer a wide range of solutions appropriate to the clients message and budget. He has been recognized with dozens of awards in business, communications and filmmaking from around the world. For the client, this means a truly unique balance of hands on technical knowledge and high level strategic experience that always leads to unique and creative solutions.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Social or Anti-Social Marketing 101?

1
Digg me

AL_HiResI’ve always considered myself a social animal. Just ask the folks in the hospitality business in any town I’ve spent time in. But it has suddenly occurred to me that my years of being a social animal may have put me at forefront of a new marketing thingee called Social Marketing.

According to the experts, social marketing was “born” as a discipline in the 1970s, when a few smart people realized that the same marketing principles that were being used to sell products to consumers could be used to “sell” ideas, attitudes and behaviors. Believe it or not I was around in the 1970s… and I thought Social Marketing was really all about Tupperware parties or the traditional get together in the back of the local hardware store around the hot-stove or… in the tents set up at carnivals – or was that more about Social Disease? Today the techniques and tactics have changed (inbound marketing, google search, twitter, blogs… yadda, yadda, yadda) but weren’t all the aforementioned also being used to “sell” ideas, change attitudes and behaviors?

The experts also claim that social marketing differs from other areas of marketing only with respect to the objectives of the marketer. Social marketing, according to these same experts, seeks to influence social behaviors, not to benefit the marketer, but to benefit the target audience and society in general. Say What?  While I doubt major brands are investing millions in social marketing for the benefit of general society, I think it is fair to say that some of those involved in more altruistic endeavours are using it to successfully reach people who share their views and attitudes.

In any event, here’s a little Social Marketing story from my less than expert communications past. It starts when… I was retained by an organization that had a need to communicate with a major group of influencers and decision makers about a product that was subjected to considerable adverse pressure.

Before we go any further, let’s be sure you get my drift…. the organization was involved in the manufacture of tobacco products; the so-called influencers and decision makers were parliamentarians of all political stripes. And, before you diss me getting in bed with Big Bad Tobacco and being naive enough to believe that the average parliamentarian has much influence on anything, remember the point of this missive is to examine the virtues of the new marketing craze called “Social Marketing.”

So… here’s what we did to help Big Bad Tobacco deal with the adverse pressures to which they were being subjected to by the nasty guys in government.  We set out to form a citizens group comprised of smokers who believed their rights were being trampled by an overreaching government. This gathering of like-minded individuals that was thirsting for, as Rodney Dangerfield would say, “a little respect” was encouraged to come together under the mychoice.camychoice web banner. As the name implies…  their choice was to smoke wherever and whenever they wanted to.  And what better way to express themselves and get the politician’s attention than to have a presence on the net? Oh yeah, there was an office, but that was only used to distribute posters, bar coasters and other collateral materials designed to promote the individual’s right to enjoy their dastardly smoking habit even in public places. Traditional advertising tactics (newspaper ads and radio commercials) were employed to drive people to mychoice.ca. And guess what? It worked! Score one for traditional advertising!

All of a sudden 45,000 enraged smokers came out of the nicotine stained woodwork ready to do battle with anyone preventing them from enjoying a smoke. Protest demonstrations were planned and executed in roadhouses all around rural Canada… roadhouses being an obvious venue because beer and smokes are tied at the hip. Individual letters of protest were dispatched (all following a guideline written by writers mychoice employed} and…. the politicians were inundated. All right, maybe not inundated, but they did get a few letters.

OK so what? you ask. How did this so-called Social Marketing adventure work out? Did it “sell” ideas, change attitudes and/or behaviors?

In order to answer that we need to remember what the experts say social marketing was designed to do…. “seek to influence social behaviors not to benefit the marketer.”  So it did work because all the like-minded members of mychoice suddenly had a forum wherein they could become an important part of a social marketing program designed to get them some respect.  Remember, this was a program designed on the surface to benefit smokers, enabling them to purchase consumer tobacco products without impunity. However, if helped smokers gain a little respect, there is no doubt that the major benefits would accrue to tobacco farmers, tobacco manufacturers and even tobacco smugglers everywhere. Because God knows… there is less profit in Soya Beans than there is in Virginia Tobacco; and it costs a fortune to package smokes in warning laden packs that are hidden behind closed shelf doors and to find and exploit new channels of communication and distribution that were less regulated.

Yeah, but what was the “Sell” benefit? you ask. Did more people rush to the local Variety store to buy smokes? Well no… smoking actually decreased.

Did those decision makers in Ottawa reduce the onerous taxes on tobacco? No… and by not reducing taxes they made a conscious decision to help the bootleg tobacco industry thrive. Did Provincial and Municipal governments lift their smoking bans? Again no.  Did all those bar owners who had invested in smoke reduction equipment get reimbursed for their government dictated expenses? Naw. So what was the real benefit?

I guess the tobacco industry got some benefit in that they were able to find a new channel to engage addicted smokers and to inform them that they still had the right to purchase smokes (legally or otherwise), And to prove to at least 45,000 registered smokers that they deserved respect, as in r e s p e c t – I can hear Aretha now, can’t you? Respect, no matter the negative social cost in health and health care, personal dollars, not to mention the obnoxious dry cleaning costs required to remove the stench of tobacco smoke from that tux borrowed from a brother-in-law.  ‘So I guess, depending on your smoking preferences, the simple answer is… Yes & No.

There you have it – my myopic view of the potential impacts of Social Marketing. Whether this little story answered all you questions about Social Marketing or not, you could always use the paper you didn’t print it out on to roll some “good” smoke (come on, you know what I mean) and light up, sit back, inhale and hold, exhale slowly, smile… and whimsically contemplate how you too can employ this new Social Marketing thingee.

From People or Planes 1974 Gordon Willson

From People or Planes 1974 Gordon Willson

Al

Al Graham is a veteran of the advertising wars who once smoked like Mad Men’s Don Draper. He is also a veteran of many social conflict wars and has been actively involved in protesting dumps, airports, expressways and urban sprawl.

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes